Home Sitemap All news Inside SL Opinions Finance News feeds Contact
RSS Feed For All Articles
 
Advertisement


We have 4 guests and 1 member online
Advertisement
Blog: Class Action Suit Against BNTF? 

User Rating: / 4

PoorBest 
Written by Xavier Mohr   
Tuesday, 26 February 2008

By Xavier Mohr
SLReports.net

Well, this is a very interesting topic that I came across at Your2ndPlace.com, and thereafter researched at  http://ossecondlife.com/apache2-default/. I noticed it has not been mentioned here as of yet.

Seems we have another lawsuit threat on our hands with regard to Second Life finance. Arthur Burma, a self-proclaimed "significant depositer" at BNT Financial, has decided to band together with other BNTF depositors and sue IntLibber Brautigan six ways from Sunday.


Per the press release:

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

Contact:
Arthur Burma
Eris Island
This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it

INTENT TO FILE CLASS ACTION AGAINST BNT FINANCIAL

San Francisco, California, February 25, 2008 - Arthur Burma is a significant depositor in Meta Bank, then My Second Bank, later acquired by BNT Holdings with significant deposits in Linden Dollars.  Subsequent failures of the bank to honour withdrawal requests and return accurate records of deposit continued until Linden Lab prohibited the operation of ad-hoc banking in Second Life.

BNT has steadfastly denied access to depositors funds and failed to remit account balances to depositors after ceasing bank operations.  BNT continues to operate and claim profits by posting un-audited financial statements, offering financial instruments for sale, soliciting investors in various entities, and brushing off bank depositors attempting to gain access to accounts.

It is our intention to form a class action against the owner and sole proprietor of BNT Financial on behalf of all persons who deposited Linden Dollars in any BNT Financial instrument during the class period.  We intend to file in California Superior court, City and County of San Francisco.

We allege that BNT misrepresented the condition of the institution and perpetrated a ponzi scheme by taking deposits while restricting access to accounts and ignoring requests for records and adjustments.  We will ask the court to order BNT to liquidate in world assets; repay depositors, pay the cost of litigation, and other punitive damages.

If you have ever banked at Meta Bank, My Second Bank, or BNT Financial; rented property, or obtained loans or funds from BNT you may be a member of the class and entitled to pro-rata disbursements obtained through litigation or settlement.  We have created an in-world registration office where you can apply to be a member of the class.  At the moment we only require your Second Life account name, assets at risk, and consent to participate.  We would welcome any additional information and documentation on your experiences doing business with the various avatars associated with BNT Financial, M2B LLC, or any of the properties generally considered to be under the control of BNT staff.  You can email this information This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it or drop in-world note cards on Arthur Burma or Rorok Longstaff.

# # #

For additional information or to schedule an in-world interview with Arthur Burma, Contact: Rorok Longstaff, Eris Island, This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it


Now, I know I sound a bit skeptical... and I am. Yet, I remain open to the possibility of this happening... so all you anti-BNT fanboys just chill out for a second.

All I can say is I have been around the block with SL finance. I have seen probably a dozen similar threats posted in the past, and to date have not actually seen any lawsuits related to SL finance materialize in real life. This person may be completely serious, and just in a pre-filing stage of finding likeminded depositors... but with regard to this actually happening, put up or shut up.

At some point, this person is going to have to release the REAL LIFE NAME of the REAL LIFE LAW FIRM that will be handling this case for me to be totally convinced. Otherwise, to me... this is just hot air like the post-Ginko, post-AllenVest, and post-Midas lawsuit threats.

I don't think a media-shy, unnamed firm is going to file a lawsuit solely relying on IM interviews with anonymous avatars. And this time... please... no in-game Mexican lawyers, or (my favorite) "My attorney does not want me to post his information to the SL community." Any nugget of credibility that could be tossed to those interested in joining in would be much appreciated, I'm sure.

It is also unclear – at least on my part – whether IntLibber Brautigan's recent BNTF depositor resolution plan will impact these plans going forward. 

We'll see what happens.

~ Xavier Mohr

Comments
Add NewSearchRSS
Arthur Burma - Here's the deal!   | 2008-02-27 00:01:31
Xavier,

All good points
Nobody Fugazi - Umm - well...     | 2008-02-27 09:17:58
I do believe that Midas Commons vs Whoever Says Ebola may actually be true... reliable sources have indicated that that may be near a settlement.

The trouble with Law is that it isn't always readily visible.
Arthur Burma - 2nd try - class action details   | 2008-02-27 10:07:32
Xavier,

All good points
Arthur Burma - 3rd & final try - switching fr   | 2008-02-27 10:09:29
All good points
Xavier Mohr   | 2008-02-27 10:44:50
I will hold my breath. I've found in the past that the second you start disbelieving something, a new fact rears its ugly head that proves your initial thoughts wrong.

Midas is interesting example that I have not touched just because it is following the trend I would expect of an SL-related lawsuit. No extreme publicity, just people apparently working behind the scenes to get things done.

Just watching and waiting from my end! :)

In any event I should say good luck to Arthur in finding a resolution to the issue.
Xavier Mohr   | 2008-02-27 11:36:33
Quote:
The trouble with Law is that it isn't always readily visible.

The only thing I point out is that if this happens, it will be visible. As far as I know... the filing should be made available publicly once the case is put on the docket.

Now, as to where to find that information online? Good question.
Rorok Longstaff     | 2008-02-27 14:44:37
Xavier:

As indicated above, Arthur made a couple of attempts to post a reply to your original post.

In light of the fact he was unsuccessful, he posted his reply on a billboard here:

Tsolyani

We appreciate your bringing this to the attention of the community and hope to provide some relief to the victims of BNT.

If this response method is unacceptable, in that it requires being on the grid to read, I will attempt to get a text copy from him and post it here.

Thanks again and our apologies for any inconvenience.

RL
Xavier Mohr   | 2008-02-27 15:00:38
Rorok,

I am not sure what is inconvenient, you are just fine. LOL -- Not sure what the problem is with Arthur's ability to comment. There are a few bugs in this comments system... for instance, when I type an em dash (a long dash) it cuts off the rest of my reply. There may be a similar problem with what you were trying to submit.

Hope my opinion has not offended you, I have a tendency to do that!

I no longer log in to Second Life BUT If you email the reply to me I will post it as a guest column. Send it to xavier.mohr@gmail.com.

Thanks.
Xavier Mohr   | 2008-02-27 15:17:46
Okay, got an email response from Arthur... we'll take a look at the comments issue... I'm posting as a new story. XM
Charles Gemini - Media Relations Officer     | 2008-03-08 19:56:31
PRESS RELEASE
[b]
Saturday, March 8, 2008[/b]

Majority of M2B Depositors Agree To BNT Real Estate Investment Trust Conversion

As of today, Brautigan and Tuck Holdings (BNT) is proud to announce the accession of an additional L$660,000 worth of BNT Financial customers
Harrison Lewis - Feedback   | 2008-03-12 18:09:06
This blog isn't bad.
Derek Hosewood - Feedback     | 2008-05-27 04:13:46
great points.

Derek Hosewood of Homeowner Loans.
Write comment
Name:
Email:(not published)
 
Website:
Title:
UBBCode:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img] 
 

Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved.

 
< Prev   Next >